By Sara Meyers, Rebel Mama Design
5 Print on Demand Mockup Fixes That Make Your Products Look Good Online
The design in your head. Versus the mockup on your listing. Same design, very different feeling.
If you’ve ever made a design you loved and then watched it turn into a dark, crooked, hard-to-read picture on your listing, this post is for you. A great design can still look unappealing online, and print on demand mockups are usually the reason. The good news is that the fixes are small. After five years of print on demand and building shops for clients, where mockups are part of the job, these are the five I’d work through first.
Transparency note: Gelato is my print on demand partner, and the Gelato link in this post is my partner link.
The short version
Here are the five fixes, in the order I’d do them:
Match the mockup to the buyer.
Show the product clearly and honestly.
Pick one visual style for the whole collection.
Use your supplier’s mockup tools.
Compare your mockup to a real sample.
Each one comes with steps you can do today. Open your best-selling or your favorite listing and work through them with me.
- Match Your POD Mockup to the Buyer
A mockup isn’t just a picture of a product. It tells the shopper who the product is for. A gift for a new homeowner needs a different look than a funny pet parent gift. One might be calm and warm. The other might be bright and playful.
Do this now:
Write one sentence about your buyer and the mood: “This is for [person], and it should feel [warm, funny, cozy, clean].”
Choose the background, props and styling to match that mood.
Look at your mockup and ask one question: would this buyer feel like the gift was made for them?
2. Show the Product Clearly and Honestly
Shoppers judge your image fast, and they’re often looking at it small. If they can’t read the design or tell what the product is, they keep scrolling.
Honest mockups are a hill I will die on. The picture should match what the buyer will actually get. If it promises something the product can’t deliver, you’ve set yourself up for a disappointed customer.
Do this now:
Shrink your mockup down to thumbnail size. Can you still read the design?
Check that the mockup shows the product’s real shape, color and print placement.
Remove anything that hides or competes with the design, like a busy background or a prop sitting on top of it.
Ask yourself: if this arrived at my door, would I say “that’s what I ordered”?
3. Pick One Visual Style for the Whole Collection
When every listing looks different, a shop feels like a pile of random products. When the backgrounds, colors and styling match, it feels like a shop someone cares about. That’s what makes a collection look like a collection.
Do this now:
Pick one kind of background and use it everywhere. A clean, simple one is easiest to keep up.
Pick a small set of colors for props and styling, and stick to them.
Write your choices on one note, so you can repeat them next time without thinking.
Open your shop and look at all your main images side by side. Do they look like they belong together?
4. Use Your Supplier’s Mockup Tools
You don’t have to build every mockup from scratch. Your print on demand supplier likely has product previews and mockup features built into your workflow. I use Gelato, so that’s where I’d start.
Do this now:
Open one of your products in Gelato and look at the preview and mockup features available for it. What you see can depend on the product.
Create the mockup for that product, and check that the design placement matches what you intended.
If you offer more than one color or option, look at each one to make sure it’s shown correctly.
Pick the mockups that fit your buyer from fix one, and save the rest.
If you want to create and preview products for your own shop, explore Gelato through my partner link: https://try.gelato.com/2h0a1zbt9i7o
- Compare Your Mockup to a Real Sample
A mockup shows you what a product should look like. A sample shows you what it does look like. Check the print placement, the color, the material and the overall quality, and make sure your photos match what arrives.
I know samples cost money, and I’m all about keeping things budget friendly. So I’m not saying sample everything. Budget for samples when you can, because you want to know what your customers are receiving.
Do this now:
Pick one product to sample first. Choose the one you’re proudest of, or the one you expect to sell the most.
When it arrives, put it next to your mockup and check four things: print placement, color, material and overall quality.
Take your own photos of the real thing and add them to your listing.
If the color or placement is off from the mockup, adjust your mockup to match what’s real.
Your pre-publish mockup checklist
Look at your main image like a stranger would, then check:
Can I read the design at thumbnail size?
Does the image match the buyer and the mood of the gift?
Does it show the real product, with the real color and print placement?
Do the images across my collection look like they belong together?
Have I compared at least one product to a real sample?
Frequently asked questions
How do I make my POD mockups look better?
Start with the basics. Match the look to the buyer, make the design readable at a small size, keep the mockup honest, and use one consistent style across your collection.
Do I need to order a sample of every product?
No. Start with one product, the one you’re proudest of or expect to sell the most, and sample more as your budget allows. A real sample is the best way to check print placement, color, material and quality.
Should my whole shop use the same mockup style?
I would, yes. Matching backgrounds, colors and styling make a collection look like it belongs together, and that helps a shop look trustworthy.
How can I tell if my mockup is honest?
Imagine the product arriving at the buyer’s door. If they’d say “that’s what I ordered,” you’re in good shape. If they’d be surprised by the color, placement or quality, change the mockup.
Your next step
Pick one listing and fix its main image today. Match it to the buyer, make it readable and honest, and check it against a real sample when you can.
If you want to create and preview products for your own shop, explore Gelato through my partner link: https://try.gelato.com/2h0a1zbt9i7o
Mockups are one piece of a good listing. For the rest, read my post on fixing your holiday Etsy listing: How to Make Your Holiday Etsy Listing Easier to Buy – Rebel Mama Design
Just starting out? Grab my free POD Starter Kit for help with your first steps: https://rebelmama.gumroad.com/l/podstarterkit
Bookmark this for the next time you make a mockup.
Sara
Leave a Reply